A Conflict of Visions - Book Review

Have you ever wondered why knowing whatour behavior?
someone thinks about abortion gives you a prettySowell believes that most of the tumult in our
good idea what he thinks about police procedure?present society comes from the confrontation
Does it really make sense that someone's viewsbetween those who answer "Yes!" to those
on the military seem connected to his ideas onquestions and those who answer "No!". He also
drug policy?believes that much of the confusion and anger
What does gun control have to do withthat fuels our public debates can be traced back
affirmative action?to these different visions--and to what follows
In A Conflict of Visions, Thomas Sowell offers hisfrom them. In this book he examines both visions,
answer to these questions. And that answer goesand how they color the thought of those who
deep.hold them. To name just two examples:
Sowell's solution to these dichotomies (and- Two completely different ways of looking at
others--I'm sure you've thought of a few) is tojustice. And what happens when two people have
look at the "visions" each of us has of the "howsuch different definitions of the word--but don't
the world works." These "visions" are necessaryknow it.
simplifications--- Does the end justify the means? It depends on
Visions are like maps that guide us through awhat you think is possible. And this will be the
tangle of bewildering complexities...Theyardstick by which you judge your neighbors'
ever-changing kaleidoscope of raw reality wouldactions. And he yours.
defeat the human mind by its complexity, exceptThis book is less than 275 pages long, including
for the mind's ability to abstract, to pick out partsendnotes and index. The first time I read it, I
and think of them as the whole.thought it was more like 600. Thomas Sowell
--but this makes it all the more important towrites the clearest, densest prose I have ever
examine the assumptions behind them. A Conflictencountered. I'm warning you, it's heavy going. But
of Visions examines two competing visions thatit's worth it.
shape much of our social, ethical, and politicalYou will have no trouble working out which side of
thought in the modern age.this "conflict" he's on. But even if you don't agree
- Can we solve the problems that confront ourwith him, you'll find the book enlightening. He'll bring
society?your own vision out and show it to you in high
- Can humanity's nature be changed, so that menrelief. And he'll help you to understand those who
and women no longer (for example) want to killdisagree with you. And maybe the next argument
each other, or to enrich themselves at theiryou get into won't end up with each of you
neighbors' expense?thinking the other is a monster. That in itself
- Do we have the potential to become naturallywould make the reading worthwhile.
virtuous, with no need for artificial restraints on